Once, Nathaniel Pastodi worked as a torturer, and reportedly took delight in torturing women. Later, Pastodi was appointed to supervisor of the city morgue by Hierarch Hemmelfart, in which position he is tasked with overseeing cremations, performing funeral masses on Temple Isle, and cooperating with the Temple Guard.
Nathaniel Pastodi is first met in the city morgue, when Geralt and Joachim von Gratz investigate the serial killer who had attacked Priscilla. The Reverend reprimands the coroner Hubert Rejk for allowing Geralt and Joachim access to the morgue without authorization.
Later, after finding a note made of human skin on Patricia Vegelbud's body, the murderer's trail leads Geralt to Crippled Kate's where Pastodi is busy torturing Sweet Nettie with a hot poker. Geralt may either kill the Reverend immediately or listen to what he has to say. If the former occurs, Geralt concludes that Pastodi was indeed the serial killer and does not pursue the matter further. Otherwise, from the information that Pastodi tells him, Geralt deduces that the actual killer is Hubert Rejk, who attempted to steer him onto Pastodi's trail. The witcher may then decide to kill Pastodi anyway for torturing women as a pastime, use the Axii sign on him, or leave him be.
- Reverend Nathaniel, supervisor of the city morgue and cleric of the Church of the Eternal Fire, was a man with a vile character – and a stormy past. Before donning the frock he had served for years as the city torturer.
- One would be hard pressed to find a more inferior candidate for a pastor than a former hangman – but, as the saying goes, in Novigrad anything is possible.
- To say Geralt caught Nathaniel red-handed would be an ill-considered pun. Yet though the situation Geralt found him in clearly proved Nathaniel was a cruel sadist, it did not prove he was a serial killer. Geralt kept a cool head and decided the priest was not the man he was after.
- If Geralt kills Nathaniel:
- Nevertheless, Geralt still felt Nathaniel deserved death. At times I have thought Geralt too eager to play judge, jury and executioner – but this time, I took no issue with his actions.
- If Geralt spares Nathaniel but didn't catch the real murderer:
- Afterwards, however, a new victim's body was found and Nathaniel's name was cleared - well, of the killings, that is, for nothing could absolve this priest of his countless other sins.
- If Geralt realizes Nathaniel is not the murderer:
- Not tarrying any further, Geralt raced off to catch the true perpetrator.
- If the Axii sign is used in dialogue with Pastodi, Geralt tells him to untie Sweet Nettie and never come back. However, Pastodi simply steps aside and stands in the room without doing so, while there is no option to free Sweet Nettie yourself.
- If Pastodi is killed, his poker can be looted and used as a weapon.